HOUSE prosecutor Akabayan party-list Rep. Chel Diokno on Thursday called on Vice President Sara Z. Duterte’s defense spokespersons to respect senator-judges’ questions, saying tough questioning, alone, does not show partiality.
Diokno was reacting to Duterte spokesperson Paolo Panelo, who was quoted as saying that some senator-judges appear to be taking prosecution’s role by challenging the defense witness’s credibility.
“Just because may tinanong ang isang member ng court, hindi ibig sabihin na may pinapanigan siya,” he said, citing questioning during Supreme Court oral arguments.
“We cannot make any inference na dahil tinanong niya ito, meron (na) siyang pinapaboran,” he added.
He applied the distinction to the examination of Atty. Rainer Dela Fuente, a former Anti-Money Laundering Council financial investigator now working in private consultancy.
“And I believe that that same concept directly applies to the impeachment court,” Diokno said.
Earlier in the hearing, Senator-Judge Raffy Tulfo questioned how Dela Fuente formed opinions on portions of the prosecution’s forensic report without first studying the report in full.
Dela Fuente maintained he was explaining legal standards and the portions shown to him, without offering a complete assessment of Atty. Alexander Cabrera’s report.
Dela Fuente told the court he had not seen the bank, tax, corporate and insurance records cited during cross-examination.
He said confidentiality and his status outside the intended recipients explained the lack of access.
Senator-Judge Joel Villanueva asked which documents would establish the original investment, the remaining balance and the basis for continuing payments described as returns of capital.
The witness offered possible explanations requiring further testing.
Villanueva’s example compared a hypothetical P48,000 original investment with roughly P2.142 million in payments.
The senator also asked how banks verify whether foreign remittances match actual export transactions.
Dela Fuente identified supporting contracts, invoices and shipment records.
Senator-Judge Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan questioned the weight of opinions based on hypothetical situations when the witness had not examined the underlying evidence.
“At the same time, dapat igalang ng spokespersons ng defense yung mga tinatanong ng mga senator-judge,” Diokno said.
“Kasi klaro naman na meron silang gustong malaman at karapatan nila bilang mahistrado na magtanong,” he added.
metrosundaily