TWO government assessors presented by Vice President Sara Z. Duterte’s defense failed to conclusively establish that questioned properties in Davao City and Samal Island were allegedly properly declared in her sworn asset declarations, Bicol Saro Party-list Rep. Terry Ridon said.
Ridon, a House impeachment prosecutor and chair of the House Committee on Public Accounts, said discrepancies in property locations, values and supporting documents remained unresolved despite the witnesses’ testimony before the Senate impeachment court.
“‘Yun pong dalawang mga assessor, ‘no, sa Samal tsaka sa Davao, ang gusto nilang patunayan na wala pong hindi ipinasok na pag-aari, ‘no, sa SALN ng pangalawang pangulo,” Ridon said, referring to Duterte’s Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth (SALN).
“Ang gusto nilang sabihin one and the same property po ‘yung mga nakalagay sa SALN ng pangalawang pangulo, whether sa Davao City o sa Samal Island,” he added.
The defense first presented Davao City Assessor Jaime Adalin on Nov. 9 to establish that a 379-square-meter property registered under Duterte’s husband, lawyer Manases Carpio, was already reflected in her SALN.
Adalin identified tax declarations and property records that he said corresponded to an entry in Duterte’s sworn declaration.
However, questions arose over differences in the documents, including a P6-million amount appearing in the prosecution’s property records and a P10-million selling price reflected in the deed of sale.
“Sa isang dokumento, 6 million [pesos], sa kabilang dokumento, 10 million [pesos]. So masyadong malayo ‘yung presyo nung dalawang mga dokumento po na ‘yan para masabi ho natin na one and the same property po ang pinag-uusapan po natin dito,” Ridon said.
The following day, the defense presented Island Garden City of Samal Assessor John Kenneth Enumerables to explain another property registered under Carpio.
Enumerables confirmed that the property covered by a transfer certificate of title was located in Barangay San Isidro, Kaputian, with an assessed value of P346,960 and a market value of P4,956,600.
However, Duterte’s SALN identified the property’s location as Barangay Matanos, Kaputian.
During questioning, Enumerables acknowledged that no Barangay Matanos existed in the Island Garden City of Samal and that the locations stated in the two documents were different.
He relied on matching assessed and market values to support the defense’s position that the documents referred to the same property.
The witness also acknowledged that Duterte’s SALN did not contain the title or assessment record numbers that could directly establish the connection.
Ridon said the testimony of both assessors failed to eliminate doubts about whether the properties identified by the prosecution were the same assets listed in Duterte’s declarations.
“Pero ang sabi mismo ng testimonya po ng mga witnesses po, hindi rin nila masabi ng may katiyakan na talagang one and the same po ‘yung property,” he said.
The prosecution earlier questioned whether properties registered under Carpio had been accurately and completely disclosed in Duterte’s SALNs.
The defense maintains that the questioned properties were already declared and presented the assessors to establish their identities through official tax records.
Ridon said the Senate impeachment court would ultimately determine whether the documents and testimony sufficiently established that the properties were properly disclosed.
metrosundaily