THE explanation that Vice President Sara Duterte’s financial disclosures involving GenCorp Industries Inc. were an honest mistake has come under renewed scrutiny, with prosecutors questioning the actual nature of payments the company made to her while she was serving as the country’s second-highest official.
Bicol Saro party-list Rep. Terry Ridon, a member of the House impeachment prosecution panel, challenged the explanation during a One News interview, maintaining that the defense encountered serious difficulties when its own witness acknowledged GenCorp’s financial transactions with Duterte.
“Well, una sa lahat, kailangan nilang maging honest na talagang nadapa ang depensa sa bagay na ito. Nagulantang lahat,” Ridon observed.
Former presidential legal counsel Salvador Panelo had suggested that Duterte’s disclosure of her financial interest in GenCorp could have resulted from an honest mistake, an explanation raised after the company’s legal counsel testified about the Vice President’s investment arrangements.
“Ang hindi puwedeng maatrasan dito ay yung fact na may perang ibinibigay, may tsekeng ibinibigay ang GenCorp sa pangalawang pangulo during her term, 2022 to 2025,” Ridon emphasized.
During the Nov. 11 impeachment hearing, GenCorp corporate counsel Suzette Balucanag-Punay confirmed that Duterte received approximately P2.14 million from the company between 2022 and 2025, describing the payments as returns of capital from an earlier investment rather than compensation for services rendered.
“Pero doon din natin na-elicit na, una, may loose investment ang pangalawang pangulo sa GenCorp,” Ridon recalled.
The witness acknowledged that Duterte was not listed as a registered shareholder, officer or director in GenCorp’s corporate records during the period examined, despite her acknowledged investment relationship and receipt of checks.
“Pangalawa, nagbibigay ng tseke halos buwan-buwan ang GenCorp sa pangalawang pangulo mula 2022 hanggang 2025,” Ridon pointed out.
The prosecution has questioned the absence of complete documentary records establishing the original investment, the basis for calculating the payments and their proper classification under the Vice President’s financial disclosures.
“So paano masasabi ngayon na walang relasyon ang GenCorp at ang ating pangalawang pangulo?” Ridon asked.
The distinction is significant because the Constitution restricts the vice president’s receipt of additional emoluments, while the nature of her financial interests and any income received must be properly reflected in her sworn declarations.
“Hindi natin alam kung ano yung batayan nito. Sahod ba ‘to?” Ridon asked.
“Dibidendo ba ‘to? Utang ba ‘to?” he continued.
“Suhul ba ‘to?” Ridon further asked, raising the possibilities as questions rather than presenting them as established findings.
metrosundaily