THE House prosecution on Thursday questioned the relevance of a video showing former Chief Justice Renato Corona describing his alleged persecution during his impeachment trial, arguing that the recording did not establish any similar circumstances in Vice President Sara Z. Duterte’s case.
The objection came as defense lawyer Mark Vinluan continued playing portions of Corona’s testimony before the Senate impeachment court.
House prosecutor Akbayan Party-list Rep. Chel Diokno argued that Corona’s emotional account had no bearing on the remaining impeachment charge against Duterte.
“I do not see the relevance of the statements made by Chief Justice Corona about his alleged persecution, except that it is an appeal to emotion that I believe has no place in this impeachment trial,” Diokno said.
The prosecutor also questioned the evidentiary value of statements made by someone who could no longer be cross-examined.
“Whatever question is asked, it would be immaterial, it would be irrelevant, it would constitute hearsay because we cannot even cross-examine the late Chief Justice Corona on his statements,” Diokno said.
He further argued that no evidence of similar persecution had been presented in Duterte’s impeachment case.
Vinluan defended the presentation, saying impeachment proceedings had both legal and political dimensions.
He asked the court to allow the defense additional time to establish the relevance of the video.
Presiding Officer Sen. Francis “Chiz” Escudero permitted the recording to continue but reminded the defense of the outcome of Corona’s impeachment.
“Again, we’ll allow it,” Escudero said.
“And as pointed out by Senator-Judge Raffy, at their peril as well because we know what happened with respect to that case,” he added.
Senator-Judge Raffy Tulfo had earlier reminded the defense that Corona was convicted over his failure to fully disclose assets in his Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth.
The defense is seeking to challenge allegations of at least P817.87 million in unexplained wealth involving Duterte.
The House prosecution maintains that the remaining case concerns alleged unexplained wealth, undeclared assets and prohibited business participation.
metrosundaily