HOUSE prosecutors on Wednesday challenged Vice President Sara Z. Duterte’s defense panel to show the business transactions behind Cale88’s China-linked receipts, saying registration papers do not explain the money flows under question in her impeachment trial.
Surigao del Norte Rep. Ace Barbers, a spokesman and adviser for the prosecution panel, demanded evidence connecting the incoming funds to actual trade.
“Dapat ipakita nila, sa pamamagitan ng pagpapakita ng ebidensya, na meron talagang legitimate business and trade transaction itong Cale88 doon sa mga kumpanyang ‘yon,” Barbers told an online press conference.
AMLC records presented during the trial recorded P319.33 million in remittances from mainland China and Hong Kong to Cale88 Foods Corp.
The schedule listed 143 covered transaction reports and three suspicious transaction reports. The three suspicious reports totaled P9.78 million.
“It is on the record na merong suspicious transactions,” Barbers said.
A possible conduit role would have to be tested against the underlying bank and trade records.
Connecting a receipt to a sale requires a documented link between the payment and the underlying business obligation.
Manila Rep. Joel Chua, member of the prosecution panel, said the prosecution was not challenging the company’s registration.
Several proposed defense witnesses are expected to discuss business or product registration and communications about food exhibitions.
The defense is due to resume presenting evidence on November 19 and 20 under Article II, the remaining charge involving alleged unexplained wealth.
“So, hindi naman namin kinu-question yung pagiging rehistrado nito,” he told the same press conference.
Barbers distinguished the demand for transaction records from a general objection to trade with Chinese companies.
“Marami naman tayong mga kumpanya dito sa ating bansa na may negosyo with China,” he said.
Chua then clarified the allegation about disclosure, saying his understanding was Cale88 had been declared as a business interest of Duterte’s husband, lawyer Manases Carpio.
The prosecution’s challenge, he said, concerned the income involved.
“Ang hindi dineklara yung income, hindi yung negosyo,” Chua said.
“But as to the amount or income na kinita, ‘yun ang undeclared,” he added.
metrosundaily