WITH P818 million in alleged unexplained wealth still unanswered, Vice President Sara Z. Duterte’s defense returns to the Senate impeachment court Thursday, November 19, with four more witnesses after a first week of testimony that House prosecutors said barely scratched the surface of the financial evidence against her and her husband, lawyer Manases “Mans” Carpio.
The Senate impeachment court has issued subpoenas to the four witnesses scheduled for the November 19 and 20 hearings. Three will testify on matters involving Cale88 Foods Corp., while the fourth will discuss the country’s anti-money laundering law.
The witnesses include lawyer Rainer Dela Fuente of AML Consulting PH, who is expected to explain legal concepts under the Anti-Money Laundering Act and identify relevant documents.
Department of Trade and Industry Undersecretary Ceferino Rodolfo will testify on Cale88’s registration with the Board of Investments.
Food and Drug Administration official Pilar Marilyn Pagayunan will discuss the registration of Cale88’s sweetened banana chips.
Rowena Mendoza of the Center for International Expositions and Missions, or another agency representative, will testify on communications with Cale88, including invitations to participate in food exhibitions.
The company is among the business interests questioned by prosecutors after financial records showed at least P319 million in inward remittances from China. Carpio held a 47.5% stake in Cale88.
The prosecution maintains that the defense must explain the company’s financial transactions and their connection to the couple’s declared assets and income.
The four witnesses will follow six others who testified from November 9 to 12, focusing on disputed properties, business interests and relatively small financial transactions.
House lead prosecutor Batangas Rep. Gerville “Jinky Bitrics” Luistro said the first week failed to produce substantial evidence against the findings of forensic accounting expert Alexander Cabrera.
Cabrera earlier identified at least P817.87 million in alleged unexplained wealth and undeclared assets from 2022 to 2025, including cash, income, properties and corporate interests.
“Nasaksihan po natin ang hindi explosive na pag-uumpisa ng presentation of evidence ng defense,” Luistro said.
“Ako, upon hearing all these witnesses, I’m frustrated. Sapagkat hindi substantial ang naging testimony nila,” she added.
The defense initially presented Davao City assessor Jaime Adalin and Samal City assessor John Kenneth Enumerables to establish that two properties questioned by prosecutors had been declared in Duterte’s Statements of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth (SALNs).
But prosecutors said their testimony exposed discrepancies in the properties’ locations, descriptions and acquisition costs.
Davao City accountant Vingelin Bajan also testified about Duterte’s compensation during her years in local government.
Another witness, GenCorp Industries Inc. in-house counsel Suzette Balucanag-Punay, confirmed that Duterte received P2.14 million in payments from the company between 2022 and 2025.
Punay described the payments as returns from an earlier investment but could not produce a written agreement establishing the investment.
The final two witnesses explained a P205,007 restaurant bill in Japan and a P256,882 Nike shoe purchase in Malaysia, both paid by Carpio.
The two transactions totaled about P462,000, representing less than 0.1% of the P818 million in alleged unexplained wealth.
Prosecutors pointed out that these credit card transactions were not even included in Cabrera’s computation.
“Banggain po nila ‘yung 817 million [pesos],” House prosecution spokesperson Lanao del Sur Rep. Zia Alonto Adiong challenged the defense.
The prosecution also questioned the defense’s decision to drop 16 bank officials from its witness list, preventing their cross-examination on financial records involving Duterte and Carpio.
Constitutional law expert Ralph Sarmiento likewise withdrew as a defense witness.
Luistro said the defense must still address the substantial bank transactions, undeclared assets and corporate interests identified by prosecution witnesses.
These include financial records presented by the Anti-Money Laundering Council showing approximately P4.4 billion in alleged transactions involving Duterte and Carpio from 2007 to 2025.
Despite her disappointment, Luistro said prosecutors would give the remaining defense witnesses an opportunity to explain the questioned wealth.
“We look forward that come Nov. 19, sa resumption ng trial, they will be presenting relevant, competent witnesses,” she said.
The defense earlier indicated that eight to 10 witnesses remained and expressed hope of completing its presentation by the end of November or early December.
The trial now centers on Article II, the sole remaining impeachment charge involving allegations of unexplained wealth.
For the House prosecution, the central question remains whether Duterte can account for the P818 million in assets, income and financial interests that prosecutors say were not properly disclosed.
metrosundaily