HOUSE impeachment adviser and spokesperson Ace Barbers on Tuesday said Vice President Sara Z. Duterte’s choice of witnesses during the impeachment proceedings has done little to rescue her defense and may instead have driven her deeper into what he described as an “impeachment sinkhole.”
Barbers said the defense’s failure to present several witnesses who could have directly addressed the allegations of undeclared wealth cited under Article II of the impeachment complaint left critical questions unanswered.
“When the defense had the opportunity to bring forward witnesses who could have clarified and rebutted these allegations, such as her alleged P817 million undeclared wealth, they failed to do so convincingly,” Barbers said.
According to Barbers, the problem was compounded by the performance of witnesses who did take the stand. Rather than decisively strengthening the Vice President’s case, their testimonies exposed gaps and inconsistencies that invited even greater scrutiny from the Senator-Judges.
“What we saw was not a defense getting stronger under questioning. We saw serious questions piling up,” Barbers said. “A witness is supposed to help establish the truth and reinforce the credibility of the defense. If the testimony creates more doubts than answers, then the defense has a much bigger problem.”
The Surigao del Norte lawmaker said the problem for the Vice President isn’t merely that her witnesses were questioned hard. “It’s that, when the hard questions came, several could not provide the answers needed to close the gaps in her defense.”
“Property records did not line up. A salary payment required further explanation. An alleged ‘loose investment’ had no clear documentary foundation. And witnesses themselves admitted limits to what they knew. Then the defense withdrew all 16 bank witnesses who could have faced questions about the financial records. At the end of the first four days, the central ₱817.87-million allegation remained unanswered,” he explained.
Barbers pointed out that several Senator-Judges themselves openly raised questions about the credibility of the witnesses and their responses to particular issues. For him, that is significant because credibility is central to any defense, especially when the witnesses are being presented to explain or contradict allegations at the heart of an impeachment case.
“The Senate is not a courtroom where a witness can simply make an assertion and expect everyone to accept it,” Barbers said. “The witnesses are there to answer hard questions. If they cannot provide clear, consistent and convincing answers, they don’t close the case—they widen the cracks in the defense.”
The solon from Mindanao stressed that the issue goes beyond political camps and personalities. “The public deserves answers, particularly when the allegations involve wealth and financial declarations by a high-ranking public official,” he said.
“The burden of an impeachment defense is not merely to produce witnesses. It is to produce credible witnesses who can withstand scrutiny and actually answer the questions being raised.”
“Instead of climbing out of the hole, Sara’s defense appears to have dug it deeper,” Barbers said.
“The more the witnesses were questioned, the more difficult it became to ignore the unanswered issues. If the defense cannot convincingly account for the allegations, then it is the evidence—and the credibility of those testifying—not political rhetoric that must ultimately speak for itself.”
