QUESTIONS about expensive purchases involving the husband of Vice President Sara Z. Duterte must be examined under the legal standards governing public officials and their families, regardless of whether the money was spent on charitable gestures or support for young athletes.
Tingog party-list Rep. Jude Acidre, chairperson of the House Committee on Higher and Technical Education, made the point as he defended the legal basis for scrutinizing the financial transactions raised in Duterte’s impeachment trial.
“Kasi maliwanag po na sa Pilipinas, ayon sa ating saligang batas, ito po’y isang mandato. Ito po’y batas,” Acidre emphasized.
Republic Act (RA) No. 6713, or the Code of Conduct and Ethical Standards for Public Officials and Employees, requires public officials and their families to maintain modest lifestyles appropriate to their positions and income while prohibiting extravagant or ostentatious displays of wealth.
The issue sparked a heated exchange during the Nov. 12 impeachment hearing when Senator-judge Pia Cayetano criticized the prosecution’s questioning of a defense witness about P256,882.50 worth of Nike shoes purchased by lawyer Manases “Mans” Carpio, husband of Vice President Sara Duterte, for young basketball players during a tournament in Malaysia.
Cayetano objected to suggestions that parents or financially capable individuals should be discouraged from supporting young athletes simply because a member of their family holds public office.
Acidre maintained that the prosecution’s inquiry concerned whether the reported expenses were consistent with the legal obligations of the Vice President’s family and whether the spending was relevant to the questions surrounding their financial capacity.
“Sabi nga ng isa sa ating prosecution lawyer, ni Attorney (Amando Virgil) Ligutan, hindi po personal preferences ang pinag-uusapan dito. Hindi po yung kakayahan nga mismo ng empleyado or ng opisyal ang pinag-uusapan dito,” he explained.
Apart from the Nike purchases in Kuala Lumpur, the defense also presented a witness to explain a P205,007.29 restaurant bill in Tokyo, Japan, which was charged to Carpio’s credit card during a dinner attended by friends.
The defense witnesses confirmed that Carpio’s card was used in both transactions, while maintaining that the restaurant expenses were shared among diners and that the shoes were purchased in connection with the children’s basketball tournament.
“Napatunayan nila na nagbayad nga talaga si Attorney Carpio ng, ng, yung kainan sa Japan, at napatunayan niya talaga na namili ng sapatos, whether that is ostentatious, whether that is extravagant, that will now belong to the determination of the court. But the factual kumbaga, the factual proof has been established already,” Acidre pointed out.
The House prosecution has sought to establish the relevance of these transactions to its broader financial evidence, including forensic accountant Alexander Cabrera’s calculation of at least P817.87 million in alleged unexplained wealth and undeclared assets involving Duterte and Carpio.
Acidre maintained that the impeachment court would ultimately determine the significance of the purchases and whether they constituted extravagant spending under the standards applicable to public officials and their families.
The defense continues to dispute the prosecution’s broader financial allegations, while the Senate impeachment court has yet to decide whether the evidence establishes liability under the remaining impeachment article.
metrosundaily