Courtesy: Senate of the Philippines
THE Sandiganbayan Fifth Division has denied the motion for reconsideration filed by Senator Jinggoy Estrada seeking to set aside the second 90-day preventive suspension issued against him in connection with the multi-billion-peso flood control anomaly.
In a resolution penned by Associate Justice Zaldy Trespeses, the anti-graft court explained that the suspension ordered by the Second Division in June 2026 is legally distinct from the one the Fifth Division issued in October 2026. “The cases pending in this division are distinct and independent from that pending in the Second Division. Any perceived gap in the court’s imposition of preventive suspension… is simply a result of the independent functioning of the Sandiganbayan’s divisions,” the court stated.
Estrada had argued that he had already served his 90-day suspension and that a second consecutive order would keep him from performing his duties as a senator for a total of 180 days — effectively turning a preventive measure into a penalty before conviction.
The Fifth Division, however, clarified that the suspension is a ministerial duty required by law to preserve the integrity of the proceedings and does not amount to a finding of guilt. The court also pointed out that the suspensions would not keep him out of office indefinitely, and that each case must be treated on its own merits.
This is not the first time the court has denied Estrada’s pleas in these proceedings. In September, the Fifth Division affirmed its earlier ruling denying his motion to fix bail in the ₱573‑million plunder case, finding it lacked merit.
The Office of the Ombudsman welcomed the resolution, with Assistant Ombudsman Mico Clavano emphasizing that “preventive suspension is a procedural safeguard intended to preserve the integrity of judicial proceedings and does not constitute a determination of guilt.” The Ombudsman maintained that each case stands on its own and that the law must be applied consistently across all charges filed against the senator.
metrosundaily