THREE government witnesses set to testify for the defense this week appear unlikely to address questions surrounding the reported more than P319 million in remittances from China and Hong Kong to the banana chips company allegedly owned by Vice President Sara Z. Duterte’s husband, lawyer Manases “Mans” Carpio.
House private prosecutor and spokesperson Atty. Benjamin “Jay” Tolosa Jr. raised the concern during an interview with Morning Matters on One News, pointing out that the defense’s latest request for subpoenas identified testimony concerning business registrations and trade promotions rather than the actual financial transactions involving Cale88 Foods Corp.
“So just based on this manifestation motion, it does not appear that these witnesses will testify on the specific remittances received by Cale88 from China amounting to more than 300 million pesos,” Tolosa observed.
The defense has requested the testimony of Department of Trade and Industry Undersecretary Ceferino Rodolfo, Food and Drug Administration official Pilar Marilyn Pagayunan and Rowena Mendoza or another representative of the Center for International Trade Expositions and Missions during the November 19 and 20 impeachment hearings.
According to the defense’s manifestation, Rodolfo will discuss Cale88’s registration with the Board of Investments, Pagayunan will address the company’s product registration for sweetened banana chips and the CITEM representative will identify invitations and communications involving food exhibitions.
“So these 3 will just testify about registration documents of Cale88 specifically product registrations with the FDA, registrations with the Bureau of… Board of Investments, and then some invitations regarding Food Expos, no,” Tolosa explained.
The prosecution had presented Anti-Money Laundering Council records showing that Cale88 received P319.33 million in inward remittances from mainland China and Hong Kong, including three transactions that reporting banks flagged as suspicious.
AMLC Executive Director Ronel Buenaventura testified in October that the transaction reports raised questions about the underlying purposes or economic justification of certain transfers, although the records did not establish that the funds originated from the Chinese government or personally benefited Duterte.
Carpio previously held a reported ownership interest in Cale88, making the company’s financial transactions relevant to the prosecution’s examination of the couple’s business interests and the Vice President’s sworn wealth declarations.
“So now, with respect also doon sa three witnesses to talk about Cale88, same wala din hong naka-indicate diyan that he will be talked about the specific remittances received by Cale88 from China kaya yan ho yung pinag-uusapan, yung more than 300 million,” Tolosa stressed.
While the company’s government registrations and participation in international trade exhibitions could help establish the nature of its business operations, those documents alone would not necessarily explain the source, purpose and accounting treatment of the remittances identified in the AMLC records.
The defense maintains that its witnesses and supporting documents will help challenge the prosecution’s allegations under Article II of the impeachment complaint, which concerns Duterte’s alleged unexplained wealth and inaccurate financial disclosures.
The Senate impeachment court is scheduled to resume proceedings Thursday, with the three government officials and an anti-money-laundering lawyer among the defense witnesses expected to appear.
metrosundaily