Courtesy: Alonto Adiong FB page
HOUSE prosecution spokesperson and Lanao del Sur Rep. Zia Alonto Adiong said Sunday that Vice President Sara Z. Duterte’s defense team started from a weak position in disputing the prosecution’s unexplained wealth allegations.
Speaking in an interview with dzBB’s “Bantay Balita sa Kongreso” with Nimfa Ravelo and Isa Avendaño-Umali, Alonto Adiong said the defense has yet to find a way to rebut the financial records and other documents presented by the prosecution, including income tax returns, bank records, and Statements of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth (SALNs) that Duterte filed herself.
“The defense takeoff [was] on a very weak position,” he said.
“Sa case of impeachment trial na ito, saan po galing yung mga dokumentong pinipresenta ng prosecution? Hindi ba ito ay mga dokumentong finile ni VP Sara? Siya po yung nag-subscribe, pinanotarize niya, sinumpaan niya na itong SALN na diniklara niya ay pawang katotohanan lamang at walang entries doon,” he added.
He explained that the defense is attempting to refute the testimony of the prosecution’s financial forensic analyst, Atty. Alex Cabrera, who assessed Duterte’s records and found that around P817.87 million in allegedly undeclared assets and unexplained wealth remain unaccounted for in the financial disclosures.
Alonto Adiong also stressed that when defense witnesses were pressed with specific questions, they repeatedly said they did not know, could not remember, or were not certain.
“I think yung kanilang naging testigo… hindi sila competent enough to be witnesses on certain evidence, on evidence that is being offered by the prosecution that is documents coming straight from the VP herself,” Alonto Adiong said.
“Kaya nga when they were being hard pressed with the straight laser point question, sabi nila hindi nila alam o hindi nila matandaan at hindi sila sigurado,” he said.
Alonto Adiong also questioned the credibility and capacity of the defense witnesses to refute the prosecution’s evidence, considering that some had professional or personal ties to Duterte and her husband, Atty. Manases Carpio.
He said some of the witnesses had worked for companies associated with the Duterte-Carpio couple, had been appointed by Duterte when she was Davao City mayor, or were friends and political supporters of the vice president.
More importantly, he said, the witnesses struggled to answer questions about the properties and financial records at the center of the unexplained wealth allegations.
He pointed to the defense’s presentation of two assessors, who were expected to establish that properties acquired by Carpio in Davao City and Samal had been properly reflected in Duterte’s SALNs.
He said the assessors failed to establish that the properties’ assessed values and tax declarations resolved the discrepancies between the land titles and the SALN entries.
“So ibig sabihin, kung hindi ka 100% sigurado, that’s your opinion. You derived it from the fact that you only saw just a piece of the entire issue—selecting just one component of any document that would prove probably number one, paying the previous owner for you to be able to purchase this land,” Alonto Adiong said.
“So kung hindi siya 100% sure sila mismo, ano ibig sabihin noon? Opinion yan. An opinion cannot withstand scrutiny of the court,” he stressed.
While Alonto Adiong acknowledged that the vice president’s lawyers are capable litigators, he said their legal skills may not be enough to overcome the documentary evidence presented by the prosecution.
“Maski gaano pa kagaling yung abogado, pero kung mahina naman talaga from the very start ang kaso at insurmountable yung ebidensya na pinipresenta ng prosecution, mahirap po talagang i-refute yan o pabulaanan yung mga alegasyon,” he said.
The trial spokesperson, however, acknowledged that the defense had completed only its first week of presenting evidence and still had eight to 10 more witnesses it intended to present in the coming weeks.
metrosundaily